Free CASE REVIEWS
1 800 686 9921
Free CASE REVIEWS
1 800 686 9921
Father John P. Carroll was ordained for the Archdiocese of Boston in 1953 and served in parish assignments in Massachusetts before being reassigned to the Diocese of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. According to internal Church records, he was transferred to Pittsburgh following what those records described as a credible allegation of sexual misconduct involving an adult woman. He served in multiple Pittsburgh-area parishes from 1963 to 1972, including St. Michael Parish in Elizabeth, St. Isaac Jogues in Elrama, St. Margaret in Green Tree, St. Susanna in Penn Hills, St. Alphonsus in Springdale, and St. Denis in Versailles. He returned to Massachusetts in 1972 and continued serving in Boston-area parishes.
In 1997, a man approached Father Carroll at his parish in Quincy, Massachusetts, and confronted him with an allegation that Carroll had raped him as a child in the early 1960s at St. Michael Parish in Elizabeth, Pennsylvania. Father Carroll denied the allegation and reported the encounter to Cardinal Bernard Law. Despite the allegation, he remained in active ministry until December 2003, when he was placed on administrative leave. The Boston Archdiocese subsequently initiated formal canonical proceedings toward his removal from the priesthood. The Vatican later determined the allegation to be unsubstantiated, and Carroll was given senior priest status with restricted ministry. Father Carroll is deceased.
The Diocese of Pittsburgh learned of the allegation in December 2003 but did not notify parishioners at parishes where Father Carroll had served until August 2014 — more than a decade later — and only after the Boston Archdiocese informed Pittsburgh that laicization proceedings had begun.
With decades of dedicated advocacy, we have held abusers and institutions accountable, helping survivors secure justice and the resources to move forward.
For over two decades, we have focused solely on advocating for survivors, combining legal skill with compassion to guide them toward justice and healing.
We are honored to have guided thousands of survivors through the legal process, offering support, advocacy, and the resources they need to reclaim their lives.
Survivors of sexual abuse by Father John P. Carroll may have civil legal options, even where Church investigations concluded that allegations were unsubstantiated. Canonical investigations and civil litigation operate under different standards of proof. Civil courts permit survivors to present testimony, documentation, and corroborating evidence that may not have been considered in a Church proceeding.
Civil claims in matters like this typically focus not only on the conduct of the accused but also on the institutional response — including whether Church leaders reassigned accused clergy, delayed notifying parishioners, or failed to implement protective measures. The Diocese of Pittsburgh’s more than decade-long delay in alerting communities where Father Carroll served may be a significant factor in evaluating institutional accountability.
Because Father Carroll is deceased, potential civil claims would be directed at the institutional defendants — such as the Archdiocese of Boston or the Diocese of Pittsburgh — whose oversight decisions are subject to scrutiny in civil litigation. The legal process can surface internal communications and institutional decision-making that was not previously available to the public.
If you or someone you love may have been harmed by Father John P. Carroll — whether in Pennsylvania or Massachusetts — you may be able to pursue legal accountability. Every survivor deserves to be heard.
Every survivor deserves compassion and acknowledgment. This video explains how civil law empowers individuals harmed by clergy abuse to pursue accountability and closure. Justice extends beyond courtrooms; it allows survivors to reclaim their voice and aids them on their healing journey. Survivors across Massachusetts continue proving that truth carries strength and healing begins with being heard.
Our experienced and compassionate team of attorneys, investigators, paralegals, and support staff have extensive training in working with sexual abuse victims.
These cases are complex; however, our team are experts in these types of cases and will diligently ensure our clients are compensated for full and fair value. We always do our best to help our clients heal by giving them a voice
and helping them seek a measure of justice.
Massachusetts Disclaimer:Herman Law has a multistate practice representing victims of sexual abuse in civil cases. A Herman Law attorney is licensed to practice law in Massachusetts. Each case is different, and results in prior cases do not assure a similar outcome in future cases. If there is no recovery, no fees or expenses will be charged. Attorney Advertising by Jenny Rossman.
Attorney Advertising Disclaimer
This is an advertisement for legal services. The content provided is for general informational purposes only and may not reflect current legal developments. It is not intended as legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Legal outcomes depend on numerous factors, including specific facts, applicable law, opposing parties, and other circumstances. Do not take action based solely on the information in this advertisement. Every case is different. Any discussion of past results is for illustrative purposes only and does not guarantee or predict similar outcomes in future cases. No statement in this advertisement should be interpreted as a promise or guarantee of results. In the absence of a recovery, no fee will be charged to you and you will not be liable for any litigation expenses.
Attorney-Client Relationship & Confidentiality
Viewing this advertisement, contacting our firm, or requesting a consultation does not create an attorney-client relationship. Such a relationship is only formed through a signed agreement with our firm. Any information shared between you and our firm before an attorney-client relationship is established is not confidential, privileged, or protected from disclosure. If you require immediate legal assistance, please contact our office directly.
Responsibility for Content
This advertisement is sponsored by Herman Law Firm.
Data Collection & Tracking
This advertisement may use tracking technology and allow third parties, including Meta, to collect data from user interactions for advertising and analytics purposes. These third parties may use cookies, web beacons, and similar technologies for targeted advertising. To learn more about data collection practices and opt-out options, visit: https://optout.aboutads.info/?c=2&lang=EN.
Call us: 1 866 850 3766 
call us: 1 866 850 3766 
Message Us 
Call Us